Why Men Withdraw and What To Do About It

Things like criticism and blame can send men running for the hills. Find out the other reasons your guy may be pulling away now! Brought to you by Christian Carter

Why Men Withdraw, and What To Do About It
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Have you ever hidden your true feelings from a man because you thought you’d “scare him away?” This is a frustrating situation. Shouldn’t you be able to just be yourself, and have him love you for who you are?

Unfortunately, there’s a common mistake that accidentally makes men withdraw - even when you’re being true to your feelings and yourself.

Let me explain...let’s say you’re involved with a guy and things are going great. But as the newness wears off, you begin to see you’re not getting what you want out of the relationship and you’re afraid to talk to him about it. You don’t want to rock the boat, but you also know that negative emotions are building up inside you.

He senses it, and after a few months he’s become distant and withdrawn. You're not happy with where things are and want to have a “talk.” What happens next?

The Biggest Mistake That Makes Him Withdraw

So you're scared of expressing your feelings about what you want from him and the relationship, and with this things build and build inside you until it happens - WHAM! You let him have it. All your desires, fears, frustrations, and dreams that you've been holding back all pour out in one big emotional explosion.

While it’s helpful that you got your true feelings out, how it happened didn’t ultimately serve either of you. In fact, it creates a lot of tension and “drama.” Especially in the guy’s mind. The tension that's created in this moment stays with the man in your life and causes him to periodically withdraw.Yeah, I know...it's immature, selfish and not fair of the man, but it's the reality of the situation that lots of women end up in with men.

So how can you avoid making the Big Mistake? I'll tell you how in 3 EASY STEPS.

Step 1) Communicate Your Needs Clearly and Without Blame

Do you secretly believe that your connection with a man will “naturally” turn into something deeper? Unfortunately, this isn't how it works with most men. If you're “assuming” you have a committed relationship, you're on thin ice. Men don't assume that a connection, being together, spending quality time and all the rest means they're in a committed relationship.

And men never respond well to what feels like blame or criticism to them. This is when it pays to communicate in clear and positive terms about building a relationship together. And you have to do this before your emotions run hot and your first talk about your relationship turns ugly.

Step 2) Consider Where He’s Coming From Before Reacting

Everyone wants to have their needs met first. It's basic human nature. But being able to delay your gratification is an amazing skill to develop. Most people (men and women) want to talk, talk, talk about what they think and want. You’re headed for The Big Mistake if you’re focused only on you when you have close intimate conversations.

If you don’t take the time to understand where's he's at and where's he's coming from while you communicate, you’ll rarely get the response you want.

Step 3) Take The Lead…Then LISTEN

Let me share a secret about dealing with men. Men are often clueless when it comes to identifying the things that are “obvious” to women as problems or shortcomings in relationships. Men are awful at initiating conversations about deep emotions and relationships. So it's almost always up to you to initiate, unless you have him feeling deeply attracted to you at that moment.

Being the one to start the conversation, you have an opportunity. Will you set an overall positive tone that opens a man? Or a negative one? When you talk to a man from a positive place of listening first, he will be 1,000 times more attentive and open to your feelings.

If you’re interested in exactly how to go from a casual situation to a lasting and committed relationship with a man, while avoiding all the traps where men pull away…check out my ebook, “Catch Him And Keep Him.”

You can find my eBook and my best free tips for changing the way men respond and communicate with you right here: catchhimandkeephim.com



I’ll talk to you again soon, and best of luck in Life and Love.

Your Friend,

Christian Carter

This article was written by a site sponsor. eHarmony does not necessarily share or endorse the views expressed in the article, but eHarmony does welcome different perspectives on relationships from sponsors and users alike. Please share your comments below and on our message boards.

Connect with people like you!


Rate this article:
starstarunstarunstarunstar
(Avg: 2.0 out of 5)
AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Comments

29 comments on “Why Men Withdraw and What To Do About It


Recent comments on this article

Read all comments

Posts: 5

See Profile

After reading this article a few times, I actually, was offended by it. Has Mr. Carter ever considered the possibility that some men "withdraw" because they are predators of women. And before you get your underwear in a wad, what I mean is that some men play a very cruel game. They want you and tell you they love you and then they withdraw because they have gotten a woman into bed and than, bam!!, the challenge is over. The thrill of the hunt is done. And it doesn't matter how long you've dated, some men do this. But by writing an article laying it all on a woman to "color between the lines" is offensive. Putting all the responsibility on women is thereby, putting the blame on just the women. And that is wrong. I have seen a lot of this particular behavior in my lifetime, and no, not with me, but my friends, even my daughter. It is a cruel, malicious game that these "men" play. If a man isn't sure of what he wants, he should be man enough to be a gentleman and not push a woman into bed only to break her heart after "the kill". Some men need to step up to the plate and not make it about what a woman should or should not be doing to "catch and keep" a man. I would not want a man I had to "catch" and than work myself to death to "keep".
- February 11, 2009 02:47 AM

Posts: 224

See Profile

Reese888 wrote:
girly22 wrote:
Am I in the Dating Twilight Zone??? Why do you keep advocating the idea that women are the ones who should adapt to mens' behavior??? In my experience, when I try to talk (and I mean TALK, not blow up) to a man about the relationship I usually get a response like "Why do we have to talk about this?" or "You're just being emotional and over-analyzing things." Which is [b]highly sexist[/b] and insensitive. "Men don't assume that a connection, being together, spending quality time and all the rest means they're in a committed relationship." WHY THE HECK NOT??????????This sentence alone sums up many problems people face when dating.[b] Men really need to be aware and take responsibility for their actions and what message they are sending to the ladies. If they're not interested in a commited relationship, then they shouldn't act as such, confusing women and then blaming them for being "crazy" or "clingy"[/b] . I've even gotten "You're not my girlfriend" before. Then stop acting like my boyfriend and calling me all the time!!!! I didn't know that eharmony was such a male-dominated and sexist dating site. Mr. Carter, I don't know how you got this job or your book published. But I feel I need to publish some of my own thoughts and opinions on dating....just to counteract yours.
Wow, I find your response totally astonishing. Firstly, what's sexist about being told you're emotional and over-analyzing? That is a statement about one person, you, not a criticism of your whole gender! Have you considered that you maybe [i]are[/i] emotional and over-analyzing? Also, you try to talk to the men - have you considered having a discussion with them instead? The difference is, [i]talking[/i] is you speaking, whereas [i]discussing [/i]involves both of you speaking [i]and listening and understanding the other person. [/i]From the content and tone of your post, I suspect that listening skills are something you need to work on, as you've really not understood the article or that dating isn't about men giving women whatever they want - it's a two way process, even if you don't want it to be. This is part of why men and women have trouble communicating. We speak the same words, but the meanings are different. Yes, men need to take responsibility for their actions and messages. Likewise, women need to be responsible for their actions and messages. Both sides need to be aware of the other person. The men may not realise that the women think they are acting as if in a committed relationship - [b]the woman [i]must[/i] take responsibility for her [i]interpretation [/i]of his actions[/b] . There is a trap which, in my experience, women fall into more than men. (And by 'my experience, I am talking about the one relationship I've had over the past ten years and of watching and speaking to my friends about their relationships).[b] That trap is simply that women think their interpretation is the truth. [/b]Perhaps what you take to be acting as if in a committed relationship appears to the man to be an enjoyable relationship - he likes spending time with you. That's not the same as making a committment. You clearly haven't both been on the same level of understanding. It's not that he's wrong and you're right, or vice versa, it's just[b] different interpretations. [/b] A [b]committment is a big deal[/b] . If you've been dating a guy for less than a couple of years, it's unfair to assume you're in a committed relationship. To make a committment requires having made a large emotional investment and that is something that can't and shouldn't be done easily. A further problem is that [b]women seem to often be seeking a committment rather than enjoying the relationship[/b] . They want [i]someone[/i] to commit to them - and that sends several messages to men. That says that there is a need in that woman, a hole in her psyche that she can't repair. She needs someone - anyone - on the outside to fix it, to make her complete. That's not healthy, and it sets of warning bells. Women like that can be needy, unpredictable and emotionally draining, and the fact is that men aren't drawn to those qualities any more than women are drawn to needy, unpredictable and emotionally draining men. It also means that the man knows he isn't what she's interested in - she only wants the completion he can provide. That makes him not special to her, and it makes him easily replaceable. [b]We want to be valued for who we are! [/b]We don't want to be used any more than women do, but whereas men tend to use women for their bodies, women use men to fill emotional needs. Women as just as bad as men for using people and for misinterpreting intentions. I have a female friend. We are very close - we visit each other at least once a day, text several times a day, phone each other several times a day and at any time day or night. We have deeply intimate conversations, we know the best and worst of each other and we don't judge each other. We accept each other as we are and help each other with things we want to improve upon. Most women would take this closeness as being in a committed relationship, but my friend is more honest with herself, she's not needy. (And before you say maybe she really does think we're in a committed relationship - she's gay).
reese, your post is so good, and rings so very true for me...communication is key...committment means different things to different people, so instead of guessing or assuming,its important to talk about what it means within your own relationship... i also think a common mistake made by women is they tend to get ahead of the man in the relationship...she's thinking marriage and he is still trying it on for size...this is the singlemost important lesson i have learned this last year... sometimes men withdraw when they have a problem to solve, in that case, men should communicate this clearly, but many times they withdraw when the attraction is fading orthey feel like can't make the woman in their life happy...and the 2 can be closely connected...
- February 07, 2009 08:01 AM

Posts: 1

See Profile

It's just three words - "I love you," but with that sentence comes a world of emotions and expectations. Falling in love can be scary, exciting, satisfying, and a dozen other powerful emotions. In this stage we address the many questions surrounding falling in love and help you ask the right questions, take the right chances, and let love rule
- February 07, 2009 06:29 AM

29 comments so far » read more

Not an Advice member? Sign up to contribute to the discussion.

Sign Up for eHarmony Advice
Female  Male
I have read and agree to the eHarmony.com
privacy policy and Terms of Service.

Create an account above to save and post your reply. This information is private: only your screen name will be visible to other Advice members.

Advice members, log in to post your reply.

Members Log In


eHarmony account holders: your signup information will not work in the Advice Community. You must create an Advice screen name by using the sign-up form to the right.



ADVERTISEMENT